Update on how Piken Square is doing. We totally crushed the two new german servers on friday/saturday. On saturday night we where matched against elona's reach and underworld and when I went to bed we where ahead on both. This morning I woke up and the entire map is taken by Elona's Reach (biggest german server fyi).
So we are now taking back our lands bit by bit however in doing so I'm convinced that the only reason Elona's reach is ahead now is because they managed to make a late night or early morning assault. That is unfortunatly the key to winning in WvW I'm afraid, a small team can capture the entire map at lets say 5 AM without problems, and then the next day the advantage in points and in supplies will be so big that its very hard for the other teams to pull ahead.
It's a weakness of the system, because theres no fun in capturing the map at 5 AM when you have no opposition, but I'm not sure if its something that can be fixed.
We are at least making a comeback and we are ahead of Underworld a server that's also been around since BWE1 and with an established community (just to make sure that all the naysayers realise that yes, roleplayers can kick some ass).