Hah, I can understand that...but the reason why I am not pointing specific things is, that those are allrready covered in the realism thread.
So if you wish to know my critisism to stuff, well...I agree with Manhelm and Blinde on that thread. What they have put out would be my arguments against some points you make.
And especially since you in many parts use pretty much exactly same parts and even sentences as the OP in realism quide...well, arguments have been proven false or made under suspicion allready there.
But one I could mention here.
Plate armor and shields. Plate is for deflecting just like shields. Shield is not reduntant in battle even if you are wearing plate, especially in GW2 universe where there is alot of flying stuff. Plate does not make you in vincible juggernaut, it just gives extra protection in form of deflecting.
Since this is abour realism, I'd check the facts such as about zweihanders and plate. There is rather long explanation on the Realism thread, somewhere after the 12th page about it.